Review – The Shining Girls by Lauren Beukes.

16131077

This book gets the gold star for over-hyped book of the summer.  I read its glowing review on the NY times, saw that Tana French gave a positive blurb on the cover, and I kindled it ASAP.  I fell in love with the premise, explained as a time traveling murder mystery.  I read lots and lots of mystery fiction and tend to get bogged down with the same old plot (as Beukes says in the NY times review, there are only so many plots in the world), so I keep an eye out for the creative and the bizarre. I don’t like gimmicks, however, and there is a fine line between neat and gimmicky. I think The Shining Girls crossed that line.

I wasn’t sure the non-linear, time-traveling angle brought anything into the story. I’ve mentioned in a previous post that we are in the age of non-linear novels, and this novel was non-linear to the max. The book’s story line travels in time, as does its serial killer. All this resulted in an effect as if I was watching a handful of Law and Order intros – travel in time, murder, go! I didn’t feel emotionally involved in any of it. The murders were gory; the descriptions of the different eras and girls existing in those times were stylized and cute, but too brief for me to begin to care.

The time-travel angle was unique, yes, but the characters didn’t pop for me. A spunky, undaunted, brave journalism intern. The jaded male journalist who used to cover crime, got burned, and now plays it safe with sports. They felt like stock characters, saying stock lines.

An aside here: I read an interview with Beukes in which she said she wasn’t making torture porn because each girl was a unique character, before getting murdered. I’m just not sure that the “torture porn” debate is something relevant to most mystery/thriller fiction, but more for horror flicks, and if anything I think this book was the most descriptive of tons of chicks getting slaughtered I’ve read in a long time.

The most interesting character in the book, The House, is totally unexplored and unexplained. Lauren Beukes sets up an interesting setting of a magical House which allows for time travel, and then doesn’t elaborate or explain it at all. It is, by far, the most standout and shining object in the novel and the only thing I would have liked to read about. And yet, there’s no there there.

The Shining Girls at Amazon.com

A top 5 list posted at Audible.com.

From Audible.com  (Original list on Audible)

Change your perspective…  A Top 5 by Kali

“My collection was inspired by audiobooks that allowed me to look at life through different lenses, and books which have opened my mind to the beauty and the bizarre in this crazy world we live in.” – Kali

1. This Book Will Save Your Life
By A. M. Homes, Narrated by Scott Brick

51qNMrprPiL._SL95_

2. Spin
By Robert Charles Wilson, Narrated by Scott Brick
Series: Spin, Book 1

51WWt52Y+3L._SL95_

3. Osama
By Lavie Tidhar, Narrated by Jeff Harding

51Bf-W+WMGL._SL95_

4.  Them: Adventures with Extremists
By Jon Ronson, Narrated by Jon Ronson

510OXflHSUL._SL95_

5.  Trust Your Eyes
By Linwood Barclay, Narrated by Ken Marks, Rick Holmes

61jwYlAe0aL._SL95_

The Legend of Hannibal Lecter.

I’ve been thinking about the sort of lost art of legends or folk tales handed down through generations in our society, and the way we seem to have replaced this with the continual adaptation of intriguing stories in new and current mediums.  Retelling stories with new twists and from different perspectives used to be a sort of individual or private act, and now as our roles have changed into passive consumers of entertainment media (television, books, movies, magazines, comic books, radio, etc) it seems that the folklore or legends are developed in these realms.  Entertainment absorbs and re-imagines everything it meets that it deems worthy.  With stories constantly eaten up and churned out anew, we are living in an almost post-post modern world where we no longer even acknowledge the level of redevelopment and repositioning going on around us as an art form in itself.  Comic books turn into television shows, books turn into movies turn into tv shows, everything looked at by a different author and then developed again.  Developing legends, retelling folk tales.  Our own version of sitting around a camp fire, listening to a story – staring up at a screen, eyes wide.  The legend of Hannibal Lecter is a wonderful example of this.  We all know him, of his almost superhuman cunning and reptilian lack of empathy, now.

220px-Drag01big

Hannibal Lecter, the icy cold and brilliant psychopath most of us are familiar with today, was first created by Thomas Harris in the 1981 thriller novel Red Dragon.  The book isn’t written around Hannibal’s story, but rather he’s presented as a haunting figure from a past case of the protagonist Will Graham, an FBI profiler.  Hannibal does seem to steal the show, and quickly becomes a pivotal point of the current investigation.

215px-Manhunter_michael_mann_film_poster

And then our first re-telling of the story begins.  The novel Red Dragon was turned into a little-watched film called Manhunter in 1986.  Dennis Farina played Will Graham, and (I think this is great casting) Brian Cox played Hannibal Lecktor, whose last name they had decided to change for some odd reason.

325082-manhunter3 manhunter-04

The Hannibal story continues in 1988, with Thomas Harris’s second book, the Silence of the Lambs.  In this book, Hannibal is not just a overbearing presence on the sidelines but he is on the main stage – he is freaking us all out with his cool-headed and calculated sociopathy, he is shocking us with his sudden acts of viciousness and face-biting, and we can’t get enough.  It sold well, it won a few awards, and suddenly the world had a favorite cannibal.

220px-Silence3

But as in some crazy volleyball move, where one teammate sets up the ball for another to spike it over the net and solidly win the point, the novel The Silence of the Lambs was really just the tip of the iceberg.  If Thomas Harris, the author, was setting up the ball, then Jonathan Demme and Anthony Hopkins were the guys spiking it hard across the volleyball net to win the point for the team.  In 1991, the movie the Silence of the Lambs, produced by Jonathan Demme, was released.  It starred Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter and Jodie Foster as Clarice Starling.  As everyone knows, this movie was a huge hit.  It swept the Academy Awards, winning Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Director, and Best Adapted Screenplay.  It grossed $272 million.

images

Even at this point, it is interesting to pause and wonder what about this 1991 film caused Hannibal Lecter to be the right thing, at that moment.  He’d been in existence, at this point, for 10 years.  Was The Red Dragon material just not as good as The Silence of the Lambs story?  Was The Silence of the Lambs just a better movie than Manhunter?

With such large successes, there came sequels.  The novel Hannibal (1999) focused on Hannibal’s life after The Silence of the Lambs, and a prequel called Hannibal Rising was released in 2006.  For film, in 2001 Hannibal was adapted with Anthony Hopkins keeping his role, and in 2002 Red Dragon, the novel previously adapted as Manhunter, was again adapted (this time keeping its original name).  Anthony Hopkins played Hannibal again and Edward Norton played Will Graham.  Hashed, and re-hashed again, Hannibal had lived on for well over 20 years.

And now, the most recent rendition:  NBC has brought us the TV series Hannibal, a beautiful prequel to the Red Dragon material, written and produced by Brian Fuller with Mads Mikkelsen as Hannibal Lecter and Hugh Dancy as Will Graham.

186492

The legend has once again grown, our giant world of entertainment like a huge collage everyone is working with, with the TV series beginning with Will Graham’s cases which have just been mentioned in passing in the novel Red Dragon, building entire story lines out of brief histories barely discussed in Red Dragon.  Fun, or funny, adaptations have been made – a fat, stocky male journalist from the novel is now an easy-on-the-eyes female (yet they both keep the same name – Freddy).

I wonder what Thomas Harris, the creator of the character of Hannibal Lecter, thinks of all this.  His character has grown into a legend, acted by many men, a mythical representation of evil for our time, the ultimate imagined serial killer of our time.  It is hard to know what the novelist thinks, as Thomas Harris is reportedly reclusive and doesn’t give interviews.  30 years later, and here we are – back at Red Dragon, telling each other the same legends with different faces.

Review – Broken Harbor by Tana French/A Case of Redemption by Adam Mitzner.

brokenharbor_us_thumb

When our shadows showed faintly they were twisted and unfamiliar, turned hunchbacked by the holdalls slung over our shoulders.  Our footsteps came back to us like followers’, bouncing off bare walls and across stretches of churned mud.  We didn’t talk:  the dusk that was helping to cover us could be covering someone else, anywhere.  — Broken Harbor, Tana French

The thrill of a mystery can sometimes be cheap – I just finished a legal thriller, A Case of Redemption, by Adam Mitzner, that reminded me of this.  And that is why Broken Harbor, by Tana French, is so worthwhile.  Tana French has created an experience here, a bizarre world of baby monitors and built up dreams shattered and a development site that seems to be its own House of Usher.  French is a master of language, and although she has written three other books in this series she has chosen this one to reveal herself as such, to come out of the literary closet and really blow us all away with her ability to write a book.  The story is crisply gothic and full of the thinking type of police procedural that makes detective books great; the characters are deep and round and real.  This is definitely one worth reading, as are the first three (In The Woods, The Likeness, Faithful Place) if you haven’t checked them out.

A note on the concept for the Dublin Murder Squad series:  Tana French picks a minor character from the previous book, and focuses on that character for the next book.  And like a chain, the books connect.  French seems such a master at character development, it almost seems a shame to keep running from characters she’s already created, and I wonder if she’ll ever go back to past favorite detectives.  I think it speaks to her skill as an author that she is able to use devices which traditionally frustrate readers, such as ditching main characters and leaving loose ends, and she still has a large fan base.

Broken Harbor on Amazon.com

51M5k-jRmxL._SL175_

It did not bode well for my experience listening to A Case of Redemption by Adam Mitzner, narrated by Kevin T. Collins, that I was reading a hard copy of Broken Harbor at generally the same time.  It really amplified for me the difference in the quality of writing.  Where everything about Broken Harbor had been fresh and bizarre, everything about A Case of Redemption, a legal thriller, was stereotyped so heavily I almost laughed in a few placed.  Even the title was so blatantly unoriginal (A Case of Need, A Case of Conscience, A Case of Exploding Mangoes, A Case of Identity, A Case of Curiosities) it really let me know right what I was getting into.  In a sort of “ripped from the headlines with a twist” manner, a black rapper is on trial for murdering a white pop star he was dating.  I listened to this as an audiobook, and when poor writing is read aloud it starts to sound like bad acting.  The dialogue is strained, the sex scenes could use some lessons from Fifty Shades as they were more awkward than the imaginings of a 15 year old boy, and even the twists near the end couldn’t save what I felt had been a waste of a story.  What it feels like to me happens with Mitzner’s stories is he doesn’t have any sort of original voice.  I hear a story which isn’t quite as full of striking characters as a Grisham or Connelly novel, which doesn’t have that unique page-turning property of a Harlan Coben book.  Nothing special here.

A Case of Redemption on Audible.com

Important book of the day – The Shallows by Nicholas Carr.

The-Shallows

No doubt the connectivity and other features of e-books will bring new delights and diversions. We may even, as Kelly suggests, come to see digitization as a liberating act, a way of freeing text from the page. But the cost will be a further weakening, if not a final severing, of the intimate intellectual attachment between the lone writer and the lone reader. The practice of deep reading that became popular in the wake of Gutenberg’s invention, in which “the quiet was part of the meaning, part of the mind,” will continue to fade, in all likelihood becoming the province of a small and dwindling elite. We will, in other words, revert to the historical norm. As a group of Northwestern University professors wrote in a 2005 article in the Annual Review of Sociology, the recent changes in our reading habits suggest that the “era of mass [book] reading” was a brief “anomaly” in our intellectual history: “We are now seeing such reading return to its formal social base: a self-perpetuating minority that we shall call the reading class.” The question that remains to be answered, they went on, is whether that reading class will have the “power and prestige associated with an increasingly rare form of cultural capital” or will be viewed as the eccentric practitioners of “an increasingly arcane hobby.” —The Shallows, by Nicholas Carr

A young acquaintance who had been an English major, when I asked her what she was reading, replied: “You mean linear reading? Like when you read a book from start to finish?”  –Jonathan Franzen, Why Bother? an essay from the book How to be Alone

Some books have a tendency to haunt.  They stick to me long after I’ve read them, and I compulsively begin to tell people the anecdotes they contain at dinner tables and in cars.  “But taxi drivers have a larger part of the brain that visualizes the road!”  “Did you know deep reading hasn’t always been a part of various societies’ popular cultures?”  These tidbits of info floating in my mind are thanks to Nicholas Carr, who has some serious business with our brains and the internet.

I’ve felt the internet’s impact on novels, and especially been aware of it as of late.  I realize it is partly just a trend, but so many popular fiction novels aren’t linear anymore.  As with the internet, they’re hopping from place to place or time to time or narrator to narrator.  Some non-linear novels are great, but I do want to pause and ask – why are we, as a society, writing like this?  Why do we all want to read books which use this single literary device, the non-linear narrative?  What about settling in with a more traditional book, which plays out start to finish and beginning to end, has lost its appeal?  Nicholas Carr has the answer to this question in The Shallows.

The Shallows website

Review – The Dinner: A Novel by Herman Koch.

51nRJpjCP3L._SL175_

This was a novel of beautifully slow pacing. A husband and wife out to a painfully slow, grotesquely upscale dinner which they admit dreading from the morning of. The drinks, the appetizers, the meal, the desserts, and all the life in between. The novel matched the meal in time – dragging in a way that was purposeful and neat. The lines that finished each chapter were crisp and the chapters themselves were timed beautifully, each chapter ending with a cut that left an absence, a statement in itself with the words unsaid.

I listened to the audio version of this book, narrated by Clive Mantel, and he took the time with the story that it deserved. Each time he spat out the family name I felt all the emotions boiled up underneath “Lohman”, I heard the contempt broiling up in way that is hard to do in a narration without sounding overdone.

I was surprised to read other reviews that compared this to Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn. Every book I’ve read since Gone Girl has been published, there’s a required comparison. I don’t see too many similarities. I would compare this to the film There Will Be Blood by Paul Thomas Anderson, for its slow crawl through the story, and its emphasis on family, social expectations, and violence. Or another comparison here, without giving too much away of either book, would be to Defending Jacob by William Landay.

I loved this book and it helped me get through several loads of laundry and many commutes. If you dislike a book that drifts before it reaches its conclusion, however, I’d skip it.

The Dinner on Audible.com

Why hello there!

I’m a lover of books. I can’t stop reading them, telling people (who aren’t asking) about them, buying them, selling them, browsing them, adding them to wishlists, checking them off my lists, reading reviews of them, listening to them. I’m creating this little site to share my love with you – the good, the bad, and the ugly.

I mainly read mystery (currently Broken Harbor by Tana French, just finished Red Dragon by Thomas Harris), popular fiction (on my to-read shelf: the first four Game of Thrones novels by George R. R. Martin), literary fiction (trawling through 2666 by Roberto Bolano, just started and then sort of put off Swamplandia! by Karen Russell, listening to The Dinner by Herman Koch), memoir (currently in the middle of In the Body of the World by Eve Ensler), and non-fiction and essays (on the to-read shelf: The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan, and currently in the middle of How to Be Alone by Johnathan Franzen). Oh, and I love a good science fiction or speculative fiction story but for some reason these aren’t in my spotlight right now.

This site will be full of reviews that I won’t insist to be unbiased, chock full of my own opinions. I like to take into account our current cultural climate while considering the medium and the message of the books I read.

All for now.